AWS Knowledge
AWS Spot Instances vs On-Demand Instances Explained
Piyush Kalra
Nov 29, 2024
Choosing the ideal AWS instance type is essential as it can help maintain costs associated with the cloud or lead to exorbitant costs at the end of the month. The simple question remains: Which is better for your business? This is because unlike the conventional options, which are only two in the case of Amazon EC2, which are On-Demand Instances and Spot Instances, each offers its own set of benefits in terms of usage.
In this blog, we will discuss the fundamental concepts of Spot Instances and On-Demand Instances, their advantages and disadvantages, and the ways of their application—what the key differences are, and when to use what.
Fun fact: Spot Instances can save you up to 90% compared to On-Demand Instances! Let’s not skip a beat and readily assist you in choosing the best option.
Understanding AWS Instances
What Are AWS Instances?
AWS instances are virtual servers provided through Amazon's EC2, a part of Amazon's cloud. These instances allow you to perform a wide range of functions, from running basic websites to hosting advanced machine-learning models. AWS gives options on how pricing for these instances can be done. They have Spot Instances (interruptible but affordable), On-Demand Instances (no long-term contracts, pay-as-you-go) and Reserved Instances (discount prices on long-term contracts).
Why Understanding Instance Types Matters
Understanding different instance types is important for your application's cost and performance management. The downside to choosing an instance type that does not meet your workload requirements would be having to pay for unused cloud capacity or not being able to meet demand at peak usage. Spot instances are suitable for non-essential applications with lower budgets; however, for more variable workloads, using on-demand instances best suits these needs. These options and necessary applications will help reduce your cloud costs while maintaining a high working performance.
What Are Spot Instances?
Spot instances can be defined as cost-effective EC2 instances that make use of Amazon’s spare EC2 capacity. This option provides lower costs, with discounts sometimes reaching 90% of the On-Demand price. However, if workload users choose such an option, they should be prepared for AWS to reclaim the resources with only a two-minute warning.
Benefits of Spot Instances
High discounts: Save up to 90% on EC2 costs, making spot instances suitable for workloads such as batch processing requiring a more frugal approach.
Scalability: Ample room to scale resources up or down based on workload requirements.
Full EC2 benefits: Provisioned to utilize all EC2 features while benefitting from lower costs.
Limitations of Spot Instances
Interruptions: AWS has the ability to kill Spot Instance interruptions at their discretion, which can damage your workload.
Unpredictable Pricing: Spot prices can change based on market demands, making price predictions unreliable.
Limited Control: There is no ability to replace the ANC tower but other services can help reschedule tasks like Spot Fleets and auto-scaling.
Common Use Cases
Batch Processing: Suitable for fault-tolerant applications, including data analysis, financial modelling, and 3D image rendering.
Web Scraping: Measures like these can be considered ideal, as the interruptible jobs can be restarted after fetching the desired information.
Scientific Simulations: An effective way to conduct computational research where there are multiple checkpoints.
CI/CD Pipelines: Ideal for testing and deployment with no overhead long-term spending.
Additional Considerations
Use tools such as Spot Fleets, which allow for diversification of multiple instances to mitigate risk, or pricing history tools to make better bidding decisions. By mitigating interruptions and efficiently using resources, applications designed to work with Spot Instances can achieve an incredible cost reduction.
What Are On-Demand Instances?
On-demand instances are AWS’s utility model, which allows pay-as-you-go payment, giving flexibility without a long-term commitment to a concrete pricing structure over the long term. Cloud applications requiring constant and reliable performance are best suited for On-Demand Instances. Customers will be charged by the second (with a one-minute minimum) in a model whereby the on-demand service is active.
Benefits of On-Demand Instances
Predictable Pricing: You can bid farewell to numerous notified expenses as you will only be paying a fixed hourly rate, which will be adjusted based on the instance type.
Guaranteed Availability: Instantly available when needed, this instance guarantees uptime, which is key for crucial operations.
Scalability: Perfect for traffic spikes, it allows instances to be easily scaled using auto scalers to prevent overprovisioning.
Full Control: Full autonomy to commence, suspend, and end instances as per your content optimizing the cost and usage of resources.
Ample of Instance Types: Wide range of options to select from, including GPU Optimized and memory to compute optimised user instances.
Common Use Cases
Mission-Critical Applications: Businesses such as CRM, e-commerce websites, etc., heavily rely on having their application on and working without fault all the time and are very well supported.
Unpredictable Workloads: The use of marketing events and flash sales generates unforeseen and unpredictable demand, which, when overproduced, leads to inefficiency, but no such concern arises with on-demand instances.
Development and Testing: Excellent environments to create activities directed towards developing, testing or consistency in size applications.
Applications Requiring Specific Hardware: Use hardware such as GPUs to guarantee performance in scientific simulations or machine learning.
Additional Considerations
On-demand instances are flexible and reliable but dependably come at a higher price than Spot Instances. Contrarily, other alternatives like Reserved Instances can be more economical if the workload is sporadic and doesn't mind being interrupted. Nevertheless, if consistency and efficiency are in question with unexpected workloads, then On-Demand Instances are a strong choice.
Key Differences Between Spot and On-Demand Instances
1. Pricing Models
Spot Instances: Charge fluctuates with Elastic Compute Cloud unused availability and the market demand.
On-Demand Instances: A certain charge is paid per second of usage without fail.
2. Availability
Spot Instances have the feature of being interrupted — AWS can reclaim the capacity, which is not required.
On-Demand Instances can be availed at all times, even if there is none available in the store.
3. Cost Efficiency
Spot Instances are ideal for any workload that is tolerant to faults and vibrant for crucial workloads.
On-demand instances are best suited for general-purpose workloads that require consistent pricing and provision.
4. Ideal Use Cases
Non-urgent stateless workloads or batch workloads are mainly suitable for these Spot Instances.
Critical applications that cannot withstand waiting are best suited for On-Demand Instances.
Cost Comparison: Spot vs On-Demand Instances
Spot Instances has offered a significant cost savings compared to the On-Demand pricing; this cost savings can go as far as 90%. Let us evaluate this by taking an example:
The On-Demand price for an `m5.xlarge` instance is $0.192/hour.
The Spot Instance price for the same instance can drop to $0.034/hour.
Now, let’s calculate the cost of running the instance for 100 hours:
On-Demand cost: 100 hours × $0.192/hour = $19.20
Spot cost: 100 hours × $0.034/hour = $3.40
This results in a saving of $15.80 for 100 hours of usage, which is an 82% reduction in costs.
On the other hand, On-Demand Instances are still an important part of the economy for the systems where consistent or repeatable performance is a requirement compared to Spot Instances. However, due to the nature of their pricing policy, Spot Instances are perfect for tasks that have no strict completion deadlines, as the workload is deemed exponential and is suitable for batch or data processing.
When to use Spot Instances:
Low-priority, non-disruptive jobs.
Different stages of development where any interruption is acceptable.
Computing tasks with short bursts but a high frequency of release.
When to go for On-Demand:
Carrying out tasks that require a constant sustained workload.
Applications with Hard dependencies and deadlines.
Tasks that can be performed temporarily within a few hours.
Best Practices for Using Spot Instances
If you wish to avoid interruptions and fully utilize Spot Instances, there are several methods for accomplishing this:
Diversify Instance Types and Regions: Use different instance types and different regions in order to reduce the probability of interruption.
Leverage Automation Tools: AWS Auto Scaling and Spot Fleets will automatically replace the lost Spot Instances due to interruption.
Monitor Spot Price Trends: Use tools like the AWS Spot Instance Advisor to identify historical pricing trends.
Set Fallback Strategies: Use On-Demand or Reserved Instances alongside Spot Instances for reliability.
Manage Spot Interruption Notices: Develop resilient applications, such as EC2 Instance Rebalancing.
Wait? What Are You Waiting For? Time To Optimize Your Cost!
Struggling with high cloud costs? Pump makes it easy to save big and focus on growth. Here’s how we help:
Group Buying Power: We pool user cloud spending to unlock huge discounts you can’t get alone.
AI Optimization: We have harnessed AI to examine your AWS usage to check for waste and immediately save funds.
Waterfall Coverage: Minimize the costs across all accounts consolidated into your AWS organization.
You can’t be serious? Yes, Pump is absolutely free.
Making the Right Choice: Spot or On-Demand?
Different customers support different techniques, necessitating a blend of instance types. During the particular time of operation, teams utilize any instance ranging from on-demand, regular and spot instance types.
Here are two examples:
Scenario 1 (Great for Spot): A business dealing in social media reporting uses its owned data to run tasks at night. This task can be interrupted and then continued later, which makes the use of Spot Instances beneficial due to lowered costs.
Scenario 2 (Great for On-Demand): A business catering to an online audience over the holidays requires the system and its users to be at maximum functioning ability and constant uptime. The On-Demand Instances are always ready for active use in such high-priority situations.
Building a Cost-Optimized Cloud Strategy
With consideration for any of your applications, it’s easy to see the difference between the two methods. Spot Instances are perfect if you want to save costs while dealing with flexible tasks; however, if you are working with core applications that require guaranteed stability, then On-Demand Instances are the ones you’ll want.
Consider your requirements as such. There’s a good chance you’re able to make good use of the various tools provided to you by AWS in unison by carefully analyzing your situation and combining the various styles of the types altogether, resulting in a befitting strategy to help you save costs.
Join Pump for Free
If you found this post interesting, consider checking out Pump, which can save you up to 60% off AWS for early-stage startups, and it’s completely free (yes, that's right!). Pump has tailor-made solutions to take you in control of your AWS and GCP spend in an effective way. So, are you ready to take charge of cloud expenses and maximize the most from your investment in AWS? Learn more here.
