Choosing your cloud storage solution feels like deciding between two superbly engineered vehicles; they will both get you there, but the cost-of-ownership and the ride are different. I’ve helped design architecture for both, so I know the subtleties. R2 and S3 are both durable and scalable, yet they diverge in their pricing models and core design philosophies. When a streaming client I worked with saved six figures by moving a subset of their assets, the impact became palpable overnight.
This guide dives straight into the technical and financial nitty-gritty, how storage costs, retrieval costs, built-in features, and real-world latency tests stack up. I’ll flag the situations where R2’s zero egress charges light up the calculator, as well as the jobs where S3’s broader toolchain and resource bounty are non-negotiable. Let’s get into the details you’ll actually use, and save you clicks and headaches on the way.
What is Cloudflare R2?
Cloudflare R2 is a highly innovative object storage platform that debuted in 2021 with one bold benefit: zero egress costs. Simply put, you store your data and fetch it as often as you want, without hidden costs piling up whenever users access that data.
Key Features of Cloudflare R2:
No egress costs: eliminate unexpected data transfer charges every month.
S3-compatible API: Seamless integration with your existing S3 tools and applications.
Global CDN integration: Accelerate content delivery via Cloudflare’s 330+ edge nodes.
Cloudflare Workers integration: Push custom logic close to your users for lightning-fast processing.
Transparent pricing: Simple pricing models with no sneaky fees.
Cloudflare R2 is built for workloads with consistent data retrieval, where bandwidth costs can snowball. Media delivery, video-on-demand, and periodic backups all benefit from a predictable cost model and the speed of a distributed platform that was engineered for the edge.
What is AWS S3?
Amazon S3 pioneered and continues to define cloud object storage, launching in 2006 as the cornerstone of AWS’s storage portfolio. S3 is the all-in-one tool that every developer reaches for, blending reliability, scalability, and a toolkit of features that adapt to countless workloads.
Key Features of S3:
Unmatched durability: 99.999999999% of durability gives you the highest level of data intactness in the market.
Flexible storage classes: Whether you need instant access with Standard or ultra-low-cost Glacier Deep Archive for decades, choose the classes that fit your access pattern.
Seamless AWS integration: Effortlessly connects with over 200 AWS services, bringing power and simplicity into one intelligent cloud fabric.
Intelligent lifecycle management: Intelligent rules and scheduled actions ensure data is automatically moved between classes, archived, or deleted according to your policy.
Robust security: Rely on encryption, granular access controls, and audit-capable retention to keep your information safe, private, and compliant.
Whether you’re launching a static site or executing analytics on petabytes, S3 provides the scale, speed, and synergy every organization requires. For companies on AWS, the platform is a seamless, trusted cornerstone.
Feature Comparison: Cloudflare R2 vs AWS S3
Feature | Cloudflare R2 | AWS S3 |
Storage Classes | Single tier | 6+ storage classes |
Egress Fees | $0 (zero) | $0.09/GB+ (tiered) |
Storage Cost | $0.015/GB/month | $0.023/GB/month (Standard) |
API Compatibility | S3-compatible | Native S3 API |
Global Network | 330+ data centers | Multi-region infrastructure |
Object Versioning | Limited | Full versioning support |
Lifecycle Management | Basic (beta) | Advanced automation |
Security | AES-256 encryption | Multiple encryption options |
Free Tier | 10GB storage, 10M operations | 5GB storage, 22K operations |
The most striking difference is the egress fee structure. While S3 charges for data transfer out, R2 eliminates this cost entirely - a game-changer for data-intensive applications.
Real-World Use Cases:
Content Delivery and Media Streaming
R2 shines in environments where users regularly fetch huge files. Imagine an image-sharing service facing 100 million monthly downloads: moving that workload to R2 could shrink bill shocks by up to 99% compared to standard S3, purely by skipping egress charges that S3 otherwise charges for every gigabyte moved out of its cloud.
Enterprise Data Lakes and Analytics
Amazon’s ecosystem remains the gold standard for enterprises loading up massive datasets. S3 plays the leading role here due to its flawless petrol station-plug-in experience with Glue, Athena, Redshift, and SageMaker, letting data scientists and analysts spin up exploratory and production-ready queries in clicks, making the complex ecosystem feel easy as file explorers.
Backup and Disaster Recovery
S3 and R2 both promise 99.999999999% of availability, yet S3 delivers distinct savings through tiering and intelligent lifecycle management. Archives that hit the frozen tier slide to Glacier with 128-bit AES, rehydrating to S3 Standard only when operators seek records, all tracked in a polished dashboard. Costs drift lower while resiliency stays locked in.
Multi-Cloud Architecture
If a team is building a multi-cloud roadmap, R2 looks very compelling. That S3-compatible surface, offered outside AWS, liberates them from any single stack, eases cross-cloud replication, and accommodates bespoke infrastructure choices.
Pricing Comparison: Which One Is Cheaper?
Comparing cloud storage costs isn’t as simple as scrolling through GB-by-GB pricing. Your actual invoice hinges on how you use the storage, not just the upfront rate. Even the smallest usage quirk can nudge the total in ways the marketing sheet doesn’t show.
Cloudflare R2 Pricing
Standard Storage: $0.015 for each gigabyte held for a month.
Infrequent Access Storage: $0.01 for each gigabyte held monthly. Data is retrieved at 0.01 per gigabyte.
Class A operations (PUT, POST, etc.): $4.50 for every million requests when the data is stored in standard class and $9 when it is in infrequent access.
Class B operations (GET, SELECT, etc.): $0.36 per million in standard class and 0.90 in infrequent access.
Egress: $0, and that is true for both classes of storage.
Free Tier: 10GB storage, 1M Class A operations, 10M Class B operations per month
AWS S3 Standard Pricing
Storage: $0.023 per gigabyte for the first 50 terabytes in a month. Price falls for greater volumes. Standard infrequent access is 0.0125, and one zone-infrequent access $0.01.
PUT/POST requests: $0.005 per 1,000.
GET requests: $0.0004 per 1,000
Egress: $0.09 per gigabyte for the first .10 terabytes, with tiered rates at greater volumes.
Free Tier: 5GB storage, 20K GET requests, 2K PUT requests per month.
Specialized Classes: Glacier Instant Retrieval at $0.004/GB; Deep Archive at $0.00099/GB
Cost Analysis Examples
High-Traffic Scenario: A media streaming platform storing 1TB and downloading 10TB each month at CDNs pays around 923 with AWS S3 before operations. However, after factoring in typical real-world overhead, complete costs can rise around $1,050 per month. In the same situation, Cloudflare R2 price for data at rest, calculated by bucketing the bandwidth, adds up to $15 per month, egress included; savings can reach 98-99% when bandwidth demand dominates.
Low-Traffic Archive: For 500TB of infrequently accessed data, S3 One Zone or Standard-IA in AWS lands at about $5,000 to $6,250 per month, plus extra retrieval charges when you access the files. Cloudflare R2 at the Standard tier runs $7,500 monthly; its infrequent access version gets to roughly $5,000 monthly as well, still with retrieval costs layered on. S3’s colder archive options, including options like Intelligent-Tiering, can trim the bill by 15 to 33% compared to R2, but R2 still plays well when the use case leans toward regular access or when you’re balancing loads across multiple clouds.
Choosing the Right Storage Solution
When to Choose Cloudflare R2:
Peak egress is expected to be high.
You need to keep daily costs predictable.
Lock-in to a single vendor is a dealbreaker.
You prefer straightforward storage without complex rules.
A multi-cloud strategy is a desired architecture.
When to Choose AWS S3:
Detailed tiering plus fine-grained policies are essential.
You live inside the AWS ecosystem and want smooth integration.
Regulatory mandates require Object Lock.
You need enterprise-grade security with extensive IAM options.
AWS is already the backbone of your infrastructure.
A Hybrid Strategy:
Many teams take the best of both systems: deliver commonly read content with Cloudflare R2, while leveraging AWS S3’s multi-tiering and analytics capabilities for sensitive enterprise data. This hybrid strategy balances cost with broad feature support without being tightly bound to a single vendor.
Conclusion
Select Cloudflare R2 if egress costs are your priority, or if you want a straightforward, low-friction entry point. Select for AWS S3 if you require extensive compliance controls, multi-tier logic, or if you are already deeply embedded in the Amazon server ecosystem. For start-ups and smaller teams, R2’s simplicity is compelling; for enterprise customers, S3’s capabilities dominate.
Kick off with the complimentary tier on R2 to validate your workloads without upfront costs, then leverage S3 compatibility to keep your options open as requirements evolve. Take a closer look at the R2 free tier or run the AWS S3 savings calculator to shape your decision around storage that meets both current and anticipated demands.
Join Pump for Free
If you are an early-stage startup that wants to save on cloud costs, use this opportunity. If you are a start-up business owner who wants to cut down the cost of using the cloud, then this is your chance. Pump helps you save up to 60% in cloud costs, and the best thing about it is that it is absolutely free!
Pump provides personalized solutions that allow you to effectively manage and optimize your Azure, GCP and AWS spending. Take complete control over your cloud expenses and ensure that you get the most from what you have invested. Who would pay more when we can save better?
Are you ready to take control of your cloud expenses?
