AWS Knowledge
Top Alternatives to Amazon RDS for Cloud Databases
Piyush Kalra
Oct 10, 2024
There is high competition in the industry and proper management of data can improve performance and competitiveness. Amazon RDS is an online managed database service used to deploy, manage and administer relational databases in the cloud. It’s popular because of its usability, growth potential, and ability to integrate with other AWS offerings. However, businesses that primarily focus on only Amazon RDS might be limiting themselves in terms of customizations and having specific needs.
It is wise to look for alternatives to Amazon RDS in the first place, because they can offer distinctive benefits most suitable for your business, such as low cost, high flexibility, and tailored functions. About 25% of companies that use cloud databases have chosen some alternatives to the Amazon cloud database when there are particular needs.
In this guide, we will go through the most effective ways to use Amazon RDS alternatives, and help you to select the one that suits your organization the best.
What is a Cloud Database?
First and foremost, it’s good to clarify that cloud-based databases have become an integral part of the existing cloud strategies (in simple words, they can be built, deployed, and accessed through a cloud platform like AWS, Azure, GCP, Oracle, etc). Secondly, there is such a special type of Database that those resources can be scaled efficiently without requiring a great investment in hardware. Further, they are also built for high availability, data redundancy, and data disaster recovery (in other words, they act even when the hardware fails or breaks). The existence of features such as automated backup, system security, and data integration of the tool’s administration makes management easier and less cumbersome. A cloud database with such properties supports multiple models of data - that is relational, NoSQL, time-series accommodation, different business and operational requirements.
Managing Databases in the Cloud
Management of cloud-based databases can be defined as the range of integrated tools and technologies that are used to monitor, maintain, and improve the bound cloud database. The most vital components would include:
Resource Provisioning and Scaling: Dynamically adjusts resources to meet demand.
Performance Monitoring: Monitors the performance, utilization, and general health of the database.
Data Backup and Recovery: Ensures that data is available, and in case of any disaster, it can be recovered.
Security Measures: Uses encryption, access controls, and adherence to compliance standards.
Optimizing Performance: Enhances query execution and overall database efficiency.
Why Consider Alternatives to Amazon RDS?
Cost Factors
For small and medium businesses, managing databases on the cloud can prove to be very expensive. With Amazon RDS, costs can escalate rapidly because of the instance-based pricing model adopted by the company. Options of alternatives such as Google Cloud SQL and MongoDB Atlas can provide businesses with a ‘pay as you go’ option which is more sustainable.
Feature Limitations
Amazon RDS does come with some disadvantages although it has a wide range of very useful capabilities. The first thing is that it can only be accessed through AWS, which creates a risk of completely relying on a single vendor making it hard to migrate to other services if the need arises. Yes, Amazon RDS features vertical scaling, except that it may limit peak performance under heavy loads of systemic elements induced to operate, due to supporting arciticulture scaling limitation, where services like MongoDB Atlas offers horizontal scaling.
Additional RDS limitations include:
Multi-AZ deployments and advanced features such as read replicas come at a premium.
There is no integrated feature in Amazon RDS that allows one to use on - premises database as a read replica. Thus, within live migration, it needs to have some customized solutions or add AWS Database Migration Service to aid in the replication of the database into the cloud.
Amazon RDS may allow vertical scaling, but there is no sharding, which is the native of any comprehensive horizontal scaling. This increases the overall scale requirement of large databases needing further sophistication of architecture.
There are so many instance types available that choosing the suitable one requires excessive searching that could easily cost a lot of money when done manually.
Top Alternatives to Amazon RDS
Google Cloud BigQuery
Google BigQuery is a completely managed data warehouse system built on a distributed architecture allowing the system to run complex SQL queries with bigness of data in the absence of a server environment. In contrast to RDS, which is meant for online transaction processing (OLTP), BigQuery has progress data where the amount of storage scales automatically up or down as required so there is no need to have the instance size determined by the user. This allows storage requirements to be maximally optimized by making use of its columnar storage which can be compressed significantly. BigQuery is also referred to as an economical solution as it has a pay-per-use pricing model where the customer pays for storage and queries that they actually utilize. Equally, RDS requires constant instance control thus resulting in higher operational costs.
BigQuery offers efficient data and compute resource management alongside Identity and Access Management (IAM) which allows for the protection of the resources under the access model present across Google Cloud.
In a Best practices for the Google Cloud Platform environment, even perimeter security practices may be effective, but more granular and detailed security of the environment is much more effective. This report also provides an overview of data security and governance that helps you identify the data governance and the measures you will need to put in place to protect BigQuery resources. Jobs refer to the basic functions such as load, export, query, or copy data that BigQuery will perform on its user. Reservations permit the user to toggle between an on-demand payment model and a based capacity model.
Microsoft Azure SQL Database
Azure SQL Database is a full-service Database as a Service hosted in Microsoft Azure that delivers a highly available, secure, and scalable relational Database service. It abstracts necessary cloud database management activities such as backup, patch and upgrade, and monitoring which minimizes administrative burden. This service adjusts itself automatically depending on the requirements of the enterprise and incorporates data protection steps with built-in and AI tools.
Azure SQL Database is a performance-tuned service that allows integrating different data types, languages, and platforms to boost the efficiency of applications. Utilized within the scope of the SQL Server database engine, it provides access to known tools, languages, and resources. It fully collaborates with Power BI and Azure Machine Learning among others and is suitable for organizations using Microsoft tools.
Similar to the other members of the Azure SQL family, i.e. Azure SQL Managed Instance and SQL Server on Azure VMs, Azure SQL Database has a free trial and then after, customers pay only for what they use above the free database allocation.
MongoDB Atlas
MongoDB Atlas is a widely used cloud-based NoSQL database system because of its architectural advantages over RDS. The basic database model used by MongoDB Atlas is the document model, which emphasizes dynamic schema making it an ideal candidate for quite a number of modern projects. In contrast to Amazon DocumentDB which uses a vertical scaling approach, MongoDB Atlas uses a horizontal scaling factor which allows for multiple instances and therefore makes it more effective in managing high volumes of workloads.
Over and above that, it offers multi-cloud maybe for AWS, Google Cloud or Azure. This API enables companies to utilize multiple cloud systems enabling flexibility as well as limiting exposure to single vendor lock-in. Atlas employs a different approach (as a non-relational database), since it can accommodate flexible schema designs without focusing too much on having schema changes migrated, which might cause downtimes or poor performance as in the case of RDS.
In addition, MongoDB Atlas provides a comprehensive range of data services such as a Cloud database as well as Automation and Performance services. Other features are access controls and encryption which are also fully integrated.
Oracle Database
Databases operate on Oracle Database Cloud Service because of the high security provided, coupled with a myriad of enterprise features. It makes sharding work efficiently, allowing for better performance and quicker latency in extreme scenarios and so can be used in large high volume applications. This service works best for enterprises that require high availability and complex data processing. Oracle Real Application Clusters allow for up to four different servers to work on a single database. This is perfect in ensuring 24/7 availability, active-active clustering during failures and thus is ideal for large enterprises with demanding workloads.
Aside from these, Oracle also allows users to go beyond the relational model to include object oriented features like inheritance and user defined types so that complex business models can be encapsulated within a relational database. AI Vector Search and in-database machine learning are also part of it and give it built-in AI capabilities. As an all-in-one data hub, Oracle’s Multi-Model Database eliminates the fragmentation of data management, governance, and access, allowing data of different types to be stored within a single database. Also, most of the operating systems run it, including Windows and macOS.
On the other hand, Amazon RDS uses Multi-AZ to achieve high availability databases, which is a passive failover that results in certain short downtimes. There are more advanced features that will allow users to better manage their crucial data in Oracle as well as customizing the platform better.
Snowflake AI Data Cloud
Snowflake AI Data Cloud is a cloud-based data platform situated above the average as it places focus on integration with AI and machine learning compared to RDS. They offer a space where users can build, train, and deploy ML models onto their data with auto-scaling features to accommodate large datasets and an integration system for easier models to be created efficiently.
While the same can be done with RDS for AI and ML tasks, it would require added services such as AWS SageMaker, needing more effort and complexity to get things done. Snowflake offers unique features including high security, real-time data sharing which enables datasets to be shared easily across multiple organizations, geographical locations, or clouds such as AWS, Azure or GCP without any need for physical replication of data contrary to the case with RDS.
As Snowflake has a pay-as-you-go mechanism, it is a viable option for businesses looking to have large data processes and engage in machine learning activities to derive valuable insights which make it suitable to organizations that look to employ the multi-cloud database concept.
PostgreSQL on Various Clouds
PostgreSQL on Various Clouds PostgreSQL is a potent open-source relational database system with the support of a robust community and is suitable for companies and enterprises large and small. It has many useful features like JSON and even more advanced indexing capabilities so that it is very effective.
When deploying PostgreSQL via mainstream cloud providers such as AWS, Google Cloud, or Azure, you benefit from cloud infrastructure without compromising on the flexibility of customization offered by open-source databases. Performance tests, for instance, often predict PostgreSQL outperforms Amazon RDS in certain circumstances, especially when benchmarks include advanced cache and indexing strategies.
Comparative Analysis of Key Features
When evaluating cloud database services, it's essential to consider factors such as scalability, pricing models, customization, and multi-cloud support. Here's a quick comparison:
Considerations When Choosing an Alternative
Business Requirements
It is extremely important to analyze your business needs before selecting any cloud database service. Decide if you require a system designed for online transaction processing or for data analytics. This will determine whether you go for relational databases such as the Microsoft Azure SQL Database or noSql databases or MangoDB Atlas.
Technical Expertise
Evaluate the level of technical skill and knowledge of your employees. For example, even though most organizations use PostgreSQL, a sizable portion of organizations will need to manage the technology effectively, which will require more knowledge and experience. On the other hand, services managed by clouds, such as Google Cloud SQL, can take off some of the admin load and hence are suitable for teams with less experience in managing databases.
Business Plans for Expansion
Consider the scope of your business growth and the scale of your operations extending into the future. A solution like snowflake, which is easily auto-scalable, can be more suitable for companies that are expected to grow very fast. On the other hand, new startups can use google cloud SQL because it is cheap and can help them operate until their data processing requirements are higher.
Conclusion
Even though Amazon RDS is a potent cloud database tool all businesses should search for others that can fit their needs more. On the other hand, businesses can look for other solutions like Google Cloud SQL, Microsoft Azure SQL Database, MongoDB Atlas, Oracle Database Cloud Service, Snowflake, and PostgreSQL and reach a better balance on flexibility and performance versus cost.
Before making a move, take time to consider what your needs are, how much you will be willing to pay and the technical aspects that you are able to handle. It is important to mention that all these alternatives have edge cases and when tweaked according to your requirements, efficiency can be greatly achieved along with competitive positioning.
Join Pump for Free
If you found this post interesting, consider checking out Pump, which can save you up to 60% off AWS for early-stage startups, and it’s completely free (yes, that's right!). Pump has tailor-made solutions to take you in control of your AWS and GCP spend in an effective way. So, are you ready to take charge of cloud expenses and maximize the most from your investment in AWS? Learn more here.
