AWS Knowledge
AWS Fargate vs EC2 which is better for startups?
Stuart Lundberg
Oct 21, 2024
What is common in the business landscape is that it never stops; there are businesses emerging every day, and for those businesses to survive, they need to have solutions that are effective. Such as the debate that is quite common is whether to use AWS Fargate or rather shift to Amazon EC2 in order to meet one’s cloud computing needs. Both have their set of unique offerings, but they serve very different purposes. This can be a game changer in a startup’s journey, if made correctly.
AWS is known for its various service discovery that are aimed to fulfill the customers’ cloud requirements be it storage, or even networking, or computing etc. So, Focusing on the different services offered by AWS is essential, especially for new businesses that are trying to make it big. In the case of Fargate the two keys in cloud computing for that are Amazon EC2 and AWS Fargate, are the best services for startups that wish to not face many hurdles when it comes to managing their cloud infrastructure management.
Understanding AWS Fargate and EC2
Understanding AWS Fargate
AWS Fargate is a type of serverless technology which helps in deploying applications without having to deal with server management. This way, while Fargate takes care of the infrastructure for you, developers can focus on building and improving their application assisted by Fargate. You say how much CPU and memory your container needs and Fargate provides it.
Fargate allows the outsourcing of individual tasks or the entire service. This will facilitate the design of applications that can be cost efficiency and also scalable.
Serverless Container Management: Because Fargate manages the underlying technology, it means that you are able to concentrate on your applications. It self-provisions and scales and handles upgrades and compliance.
Secure Workload Isolation: Fargate provides managed workloads in each pod; this delivers secure boundaries between workloads providing ideal solutions for multi-tenant or sensitive applications. For enhanced security it connects to VPCs.
Compliance and Debugging: Fargate is certified and maintains industry standards and provides a secure debugging terminal access so there is no need to authenticate into servers.
Seamless Integration: Fargate integrates easily with other AWS services to enable identity management, monitoring, scaling, and cost management. It also supports the migration of .NET applications to Windows Containers.
Understanding Amazon EC2
Amazon EC2 is a service by AWS that allows its users to rent out virtual servers for their intended applications and websites on the internet. In simpler words, it facilitates cloud-based compute resources that can be scaled up or down based on computational EC2 instances.
Variety of Instance Types: A plethora of options containing many instance types that are suited for specific functions with various CPU, memory and storage configurations.
Scalability: Ability of EC2 to change computing power and either add more of it or reduce it based more on demand changing traffic levels.
Storage Options: Block storage can be attached to instances using EBS volumes while file storage can be easily accessed through Amazon EFS.
Advanced Networking: Diverse networks such as elastic IPs and load balancing helps in bettering the performance and distributing the load effectively .
User-Friendly Management: EC2 resources can be utilized and handled using a web-based interface or using automated scripts. This makes it easy to integrate with other services offered by AWS such as S3 or RDS.
What’s the difference between Fargate and EC2?
Management and Maintenance
Fargate comes with a great advantage of easy management because there is no need to tackle the underlying container infrastructure. In contrast, EC2 requires the companies that want to operate on it to manage the virtual machine’s maintenance. This change is crucial since it dictates the availability of resources and the technical know-how needed. As such, because of the limited size of its IT resources, this makes Fargate a more suitable option for startups.
Deployment and Setup
Setting up applications in Fargate is rather simple, you just input your requirements, and AWS takes care of everything else. However, the Fargate Container service requires more than just the defining of future load, as it will involve virtual machines set up. Hence, Fargate would seem quicker for startups looking to scale faster than EC2.
Scalability
Fargate is more efficient in optimizing the scaling of resources required according to the server loads, because it automatically adjusts itself according to demand. EC2 relies on manual scaling which permits ease of management but is more tedious. Scaling in Startups with inconsistent workloads will find Fargate more favorable for effortless expansion.
Performance Considerations
Resource Allocation
According to the needs of each container, Fargate efficiently provision resources to deliver stable performance, while EC2 provides start-ups with details over the resources which allows performance tuning. Thus, the decision rests on whether your start-up is looking for simplicity or greater use of customization features.
Startup Time
Fargate is center stage here as it offers low idle times – on average around seconds which is suitable for many services that require fast availability. Conversely, launching an EC2 instance would require several minutes. For fast-paced start-ups, the difference in start-up time will be fairly advantageous.
Pricing Models
Cost Structure of AWS Fargate
AWS Fargate pricing starts on the per-request basis and the request is based on vCPU, memory and amount of time that the request runs for. This is great for startups that have a variance in demands for resources since it allows for economical expansion without any prior investments. Fargate also has its pay-as-you-go pricing, which makes sure that there are enough solutions for varying workloads and budgets for all businesses so that there is variation and optimization.
Cost Structure of Amazon EC2
Similarly, Amazon EC2 offers numerous pricing schemes which are designed for multiple business cases. These include: On-demand, Reserved and Spot instances:
On-demand instances: It is charged on an hourly basis, therefore allowing use of the compute for slightly longer processes but not locking customers into using it for a long time for demanding processes.
Reserved instances: By acquiring instances for a certain period of time, at a bulk rate discount, is effective for predictable workloads with constant resource requirements.
Spot instances: Buy the unused EC2 capacity at lower prices through bidding even for workloads that have the tolerance for intermittent use at a low EC2 instance cost This allows for great savings in usage cost.
To know more about Amazon EC2 Cost, refer to this article to understand a better explained version.
Security Features
Security in Fargate
Fargate enjoys some of the security benefits of AWS’s baseline security, as the risks are reduced by offloading the management of the infrastructure to AWS. It follows the minimum industry standards by integrating IAM role-based RBAC and AWS security groups, which allows for detailed management of access control and network rules respectively, thus making it suitable for start-ups who are dealing with sensitive information.
Security in EC2
The security of EC2 is decided by the configurations set by the start-up while setting it up. This gives more power to the customers but at the same time, it also requires active management to have in place effective security measures. Some housekeeping will need to be done such as doing a security hardening of the operating systems and applying security updates on software as well as doing correct configurations of security groups controlling network reachability to your containers.
Use Cases for Startups
AWS Fargate
AWS Fargate is appropriate for microservices-oriented startups as it can handle the auto-scaling and painless deployments. It is also well suited for tasks that are event-based and experience sudden increases in demand as it handles such traffic peaks easily. A perfectly organized scaling of a real-time messaging application at high load hours is why Fargate should be used, especially when it comes to development and testing as it cuts down on the amount of time needed to deploy.
Amazon EC2
Amazon EC2 is best suited for companies that require great detail about performance and hardware, for instance a data analytic platform. It forms a part of the virtualization machine environment of legacy applications as well as guarantees higher security. Managed workloads for consistent load can leverage the cost benefits of reserved or spot instances on EC2 at optimal levels.
Pros and Cons Summary
Pros of EC2:
Flexibility: There are more than 750 EC2 instance types that enable customers to choose the right combination of CPU, memory and storage that meet their needs precisely.
Control: This system grants greater authority with respect to the compute layer and the hardware components. With this authority, custom applications and software can be installed and resources can be managed at the operating system level.
Cost Optimization: Savings Plans help to reduce the expenses by agreeing to a certain level of usage. For that reason, EC2 is a good choice for predictable workloads and long term projects.
Compliance: This is especially important in industries with regulations, one is it allows essential software packages to be installed on custom AMIs.
Cons of EC2:
Complexity: More control tends to mean more complexities, which requires time and expertise to patch OS and ensure the security of the VM's that has been created.
Scaling Challenges: Manual adjustments are required for auto-scaling policies, and instance fleet management. This is more complex in comparison to the automated scaling of Fargate.
Pros of Fargate:
Serverless: In many instances managing servers is redundant, hence teams can concentrate on applications.
Scalability: Applications can automatically scale ensuring that varying loads are managed with ease, this is key for start ups and rapidly expanding apps.
Security: The risk is lowered due to AWS handling the base infrastructure.
Cons of Fargate:
Higher Cost: Fargate is generally more costly than EC2 for the same workloads, however, Fargate Spot might be a good way to manage costs.
Billing/Reporting Challenges: Complicated cost reporting and allocation, requiring tag propagation to tasks for accurate tracking, unlike the straightforward tagging in EC2.
Final Recommendations for Startups
When you use AWS Fargate or decide to go with EC2, make sure it's in line with the long-term goals of your startup. Assess your resource availability and workload requirements as well as any other technical capabilities you may have before making this decision. It is also important to note that, while both Fargate and EC2 have great capabilities, it is best when the solution fits the business strategy best to have chances for success in the cloud.
The best advice I can give is if you do plan on cost cutting on EC2, make sure you use Pump. We're the only ones who can cut costs on EC2 to such an extent. For example, if your previous bill was $100, you could end up paying just $41 after switching to Pump – that’s a 59% cut! The amount of savings increases as EC2's usage increases.
AWS specialists or cloud cost calculators can give you an understanding of what you may earn and get via the cloud. Avoid the cas of neglecting the need to focus on cost due to preferring control and customization of Fargate or separate from the management of complexity with EC2 as AWS does allow growth in your start up in the tech world.
Join Pump for Free
If you found this post interesting, consider checking out Pump, which can save you up to 60% off AWS for early-stage startups, and it’s completely free (yes, that's right!). Pump has tailor-made solutions to take you in control of your AWS and GCP spend in an effective way. So, are you ready to take charge of cloud expenses and maximize the most from your investment in AWS? Learn more here.
